CWCI Study Examines Cumulative Trauma and Litigated Claims in California Workers' Comp
A new California Workers' Compensation Institute (CWCI) study shows that almost half of all litigated claims in the LA Basin are cumulative trauma (CT) claims that involve physical or mental injuries that arise over time from repetitive stress, motion, or exposures, rather than from a specific event or accident.
The CWCI study, based on a sample of 1.4 million California work injury claims with 2010 to 2022 carrier notice dates, examines the growth of CT claims as a share of litigated claims in the California workers' compensation system and explores the claim characteristics most associated with CT claims. The study found that statewide, CT claims increased from 29.4% to 37.5% of all litigated claims over the 13-year study period. Regional results showed that over that same period, CT claims' share of all litigated claims was fairly stable in Northern California and the Central Valley, but increased in 2022, while in Southern California CT claims' share of the litigated claims increased steadily throughout the period. The sharpest increase was in the Inland Empire/Orange County, where CT claims jumped from 30.2% of the litigated claims in 2010 to 40.6% in 2022, slightly more than the increase in Los Angeles County, where CT claims went from 38.6% to 48.7% of the litigated claims, and San Diego where CT claims increased from 25.0% of the litigated claims to 33.4%. A regression analysis, which controls for the influence of other variables, showed that the differences between the regions were only partially explained by differences in other underlying claim characteristics. Other key findings include:
- Other than regional factors, differences in tenure had the strongest impact on differential CT rates. Employees with less than a year of tenure at the time of injury had a much lower CT rate (26.0%) than more tenured workers, as CT rates increased incrementally as tenure increased, climbing as high as 49.0% among workers with more than 10 years on the job.
- A review of the CT rates across nine major industry sectors showed that CT claims were most prevalent in the manufacturing sector, where they accounted for nearly half (48.8%) of the litigated claims, which was almost twice the proportion noted in the construction sector. The food service sector had the second highest CT rate, with 46.9% of the claims in this sector involving CT injuries, while the agriculture sector had the lowest CT rate (24.2%). Regression results showed that while the type of industry influences CT rates, for most sectors other factors such as region and job tenure play a comparable role.
- Workers under the age of 30 had a somewhat lower CT rate (28.3%) than workers who are over 30, whose CT rates ranged from 35.1% to 38.8%, though more than a third of all CT claims in the study involved injured workers who were under 40. Regression analysis showed that age is not a strong predictor of CT rates compared to other factors.
- CT rates were considerably higher for workers at the lower end of the wage scale, with CT rates of 40.0% for workers making less than $300 per week and 42.1% for those earning $300 to $599 per week. In contrast, workers making more than $900 per week all had similar CT rates, with CT claims representing between 30.0% and 31.7% of their litigated claims. As with age, regression analysis showed that the employee's average weekly wage is not a strong predictor of CT rates compared to other factors.
CWCI's analysis of CT claims has been published in a Research Note, Cumulative Trauma and Litigated Claims in the California Workers' Compensation System. The report is available to the public here, and is available to CWCI members and research subscribers who log in to the Research section of the website here.
News published on and distributed by:
