Le Lézard
Classified in: Mining industry
Subject: Letter

Pentwater Issues Open Letter to Turquoise Hill Demanding Transparency and Accountability


Pentwater Capital Management LP ("Pentwater"), the largest minority shareholder of Turquoise Hill Resources Ltd. ("Turquoise Hill") (TSX:TRQ) (NYSE:TRQ), has written the attached letter to the TRQ Board of Directors:

Dear Members of the Board of Directors:

You have failed to disclose the damning findings of the Independent Consulting Group (ICG) Report that TRQ itself commissioned:

These are some of the findings from the Independent Consulting Group, the Experts1 hired by TRQ to investigate the cost overruns and schedule delays at TRQ's underground mine. You received this 157 page Independent Report and the companion Peer Review Report (conducted by your own consultant John Barber and Rio's former block caving expert Allan Moss) over three months ago. However, in those three months, you haven't disclosed the report's conclusions or explained what TRQ intends to do in response to the results of this Independent Report. Instead, all you have said is that you, "will seek a number of clarifications and supporting detailed explanations for certain of the broad conclusions [the ICG Report] contains. The company will update the market as appropriate."

Obviously, any owner of a part of the underground mine would be very upset upon learning that Rio Tinto mismanaged the construction of the underground, misled investors by not disclosing the known and material schedule delays and cost overruns, and then lied about the cause of the cost overruns and schedule delays by fabricating a fictitious narrative about adverse ground conditions. Any owner of the mine would want transparency and accountability. Any owner of the mine would want to hold its contractor, Rio Tinto, accountable. Unfortunately for TRQ's minority investors, they are represented by Rio's hand-picked Board of Directors.

The Independent Report concludes that geotechnical issues did not significantly impact the mine schedule or explain over 95% of the cost overruns. Why does TRQ continue to remain silent on this issue? Why is the TRQ Board not aggressively pursuing its reckless and dishonest contractor, Rio Tinto? You said that you intended to, "update the market as appropriate." Since you plan to come out with earnings this afternoon and have an analyst call tomorrow morning, I would suggest to you that NOW is the appropriate time to update the market about your response to the Independent Report, given your failure to do so for the past three months.

Your lack of transparency to minority shareholders is the worst I have seen in my career. Your efforts to protect Rio Tinto, your majority shareholder, to the detriment of your minority shareholders is scandalous. Your failure to allow minority shareholder representation on the TRQ board is a complete failure of corporate governance. Asking for your former CEO's resignation because he was willing to investigate the cost overruns rather than sweep them under the rug is corrupt.

As a result of Rio's mismanagement of the construction of the underground mine and Rio's fabricated story about poor ground conditions, the government of Mongolia is seeking financial restitution so that it is compensated for its 34% share of the financial losses associated with the cost overruns and schedule delays. This is a logical course of action, and TRQ should also be looking to Rio Tinto for financial reparations for Rio's mismanagement of the underground construction. Instead, if history is any guide, Rio Tinto will utilize its control over TRQ to attempt to get TRQ to compensate the government of Mongolia for harm caused by Rio Tinto, rather than Rio compensating both the Government and TRQ's minority shareholders. Should this be your plan, I sincerely hope that your D&O liability insurance is paid in full because it is difficult to understand how minority investors won't take decisive action in these circumstances.

You owe a duty to your shareholders to immediately:

It is never too late to do the right thing. Please begin by making honest and complete disclosures to your minority shareholders. Then start making decisions which have the effect of treating all your shareholders fairly. If you cannot fulfill these basic fiduciary obligations to your minority shareholders, I suggest that you all resign.

Pentwater continues to hope that you will change course and do the right thing.

Regards,

Matthew Halbower
Chief Executive Officer
Pentwater Capital Management

1 Five of the eight independent consultants behind the ICG's Final Report worked directly on the Oyu Tolgoi project for Rio Tinto and TRQ.

 


These press releases may also interest you

17 mai 2024
Further to the news release of April 26, 2024, Gabriel Resources Ltd. or ("Gabriel" or the "Company") is pleased to announce that it has completed closing of an initial tranche of its previously disclosed non-brokered private...

17 mai 2024
Big Tree Carbon Inc. (the "Company" or "Big Tree") wishes to announce that it is extending its non-brokered private placement, announced on April 2, 2024, of up to 6,000,000 working capital units (the "WC Units") of the...

17 mai 2024
Hemlo Explorers Inc. (the "Company") is pleased to announce that it has received final approval from the Canadian Securities Exchange (the "CSE") to list the Company's common shares ("Common Shares") on the CSE (the "Listing"). In connection...

17 mai 2024
ExGen Resources Inc. ("ExGen", the "Company") is pleased to provide an update in respect of Phoenix Copper Ltd.'s ("Phoenix") exploration and development activities at the Empire Mine Project in Custer County, Idaho, USA, further to Phoenix's news...

17 mai 2024
Wabtec Corporation announced today that its Board of Directors declared a regular quarterly common dividend of 20 cents per share, payable on June 11, 2024, to holders of record on May 28, 2024. About Wabtec Wabtec Corporation is...

17 mai 2024
Lithium Ionic Corp. reports that it has filed the independent NI 43-101 compliant technical report for its Salinas Lithium Project ("Salinas" or the "Project") in Minas Gerais State, Brazil, related to an initial Mineral Resource Estimate ("MRE")...



News published on and distributed by: